Key Moments

1. 25’ McAtee Hits the Post: Manchester United nearly paid for a defensive lapse when James McAtee’s curling effort hit the post after receiving a pass from Oscar Bobb. This moment highlighted City’s early dominance in the match[1].
2. 31’ United’s Missed Opportunity: Amad Diallo had a chance to open the scoring for United but his pass to Mason Mount was too strong, resulting in a missed opportunity[1].
3. 54’ Bruno’s Offside Goal: Bruno Fernandes thought he had scored a brilliant goal, only for it to be ruled offside. His curling shot past Ederson was a standout moment despite not counting[1].
4. 75’ Rashford Strikes the Post: Marcus Rashford came close to scoring for United, hitting the post with a shot that could have given them the lead[1].
5. 82’ Garnacho Scores for United: Alejandro Garnacho broke the deadlock with a well-taken goal, cutting inside and finishing past Ederson to put United 1-0 up[1][3].
6. 89’ Silva Equalizes for City: Bernardo Silva headed in a cross from Oscar Bobb to equalize for City, sending the game to penalties[1][3].
7. Penalty Shootout Drama: The shootout ended 7-6 in City’s favor after Jonny Evans missed for United and Manuel Akanji scored the decisive penalty for City[1][5][6].

Match Overview

The 2024 FA Community Shield clash between Manchester City and Manchester United was a thrilling encounter that ended with City winning 7-6 on penalties after a 1-1 draw in regular time. The match, held at Wembley Stadium, was a showcase of tactical prowess and individual brilliance, setting the tone for the upcoming Premier League season.

First Half

The first half was characterized by a cautious approach from both teams, with City slightly edging possession and creating more dangerous opportunities. Oscar Bobb, who was later named Player of the Match, was instrumental in City’s attacking play, delivering a sublime assist for Bernardo Silva’s equalizer. United, however, were not without their chances, as Amad Diallo and Marcus Rashford both came close to scoring.

Second Half

The second half saw an increase in intensity, with both teams pushing for the opener. United’s persistence paid off when substitute Alejandro Garnacho scored a fantastic goal in the 82nd minute. However, City’s resilience was evident as they equalized through Bernardo Silva’s header in the 89th minute, ensuring the match went to penalties.

Penalty Shootout

The penalty shootout was a nerve-wracking affair, with both teams displaying composure under pressure. Ultimately, it was City’s Manuel Akanji who sealed the victory after Jonny Evans missed his spot-kick for United.

Player Ratings

Manchester City

• Ederson (6): Made crucial saves but was beaten by Garnacho’s precise finish.
• Rico Lewis (6): Solid defensively but offered little going forward.
• Manuel Akanji (7): Reliable at the back and scored the winning penalty.
• Ruben Dias (6): Commanding presence but struggled with United’s pace.
• Josko Gvardiol (7): Impressive debut, showing composure and strength.
• Alex O’Reilly (6): Worked hard in midfield but lacked creativity.
• Mateo Kovacic (7): Controlled the tempo and linked play effectively.
• James McAtee (6): Energetic performance, unlucky not to score.
• Oscar Bobb (8): Outstanding performance, providing an assist and causing problems for United’s defense.
• Erling Haaland (6): Quiet game by his standards, failed to make a significant impact.
• Jeremy Doku (6): Showed flashes of skill but was largely contained.

Manchester United

• Andre Onana (6): Made several important saves but couldn’t stop Silva’s header.
• Lisandro Martinez (6): Strong in defense but caught out for the equalizer.
• Jonny Evans (6): Solid performance marred by his penalty miss.
• Harry Maguire (6): Defended well but lacked pace against City’s attackers.
• Diogo Dalot (6): Provided width but was defensively vulnerable.
• Casemiro (7): Dominant in midfield, breaking up City’s attacks.
• Kobbie Mainoo (6): Promising display, showing maturity beyond his years.
• Mason Mount (6): Worked hard but missed a crucial chance.
• Amad Diallo (7): Bright performance, creating chances and linking play.
• Marcus Rashford (6): Hit the post and was a constant threat but lacked finishing touch.
• Bruno Fernandes (7): Influential in attack, unlucky with his disallowed goal.

FAQs

Q: How did Manchester City win the Community Shield?

A: Manchester City won the Community Shield by defeating Manchester United 7-6 on penalties after the match ended 1-1 in regular time.

Q: Who scored the goals in the match?

A: Alejandro Garnacho scored for Manchester United, while Bernardo Silva equalized for Manchester City.

Q: Who was the Player of the Match?

A: Oscar Bobb of Manchester City was named Player of the Match for his impressive performance, including an assist for the equalizing goal.

Q: What were the key moments of the match?

A: Key moments included McAtee hitting the post, Rashford’s missed chance, Garnacho’s goal, Silva’s late equalizer, and the penalty shootout.

Q: What are the next fixtures for Manchester City and Manchester United?

• Manchester City: Their next fixture is against Arsenal in the Premier League.
• Manchester United: They will face Fulham in their Premier League opener.

Citations:
[1] https://www.eurosport.com/football/community-shield/2024-2025/manchester-united-v-manchester-city-community-shield-live_sto10285885/story.shtml
[2] https://theanalyst.com/2024/08/manchester-city-vs-manchester-united-community-shield-2024-live/
[3] https://www.manutd.com/en/news/detail/match-report-2024-fa-community-shield-man-city-v-man-utd
[4] https://www.independent.co.uk/sport/football/man-city-manchester-united-live-stream-score-result-2024-b2594014.html
[5] https://www.espn.com/soccer/report//gameId/702836
[6] https://www.premierleague.com/news/4079897
[7] https://www.mancity.com/news/mens/community-shield-manchester-united-match-report-63858889
[8] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Q4esMc-EA